How to Be a Successful Landlord in the Poconos

Are you a Successful Landlord?

The Pocono Mountains attract renters year-round, whether they are long-term tenants, vacationers, or seasonal visitors. As a landlord, this presents a great opportunity—but it also comes with challenges. To maximize your rental income and ensure a smooth landlord-tenant experience, follow these key steps to becoming a successful landlord in the Poconos.

Choose the Right Property

Success starts with selecting the right rental property. When investing in the Poconos, consider:

✔ Location:  Properties near attractions like ski resorts, lakes, or hiking trails tend to have strong rental demand.
✔ Property Type:  Decide between a single-family home, condo, or multi-unit property based on your target tenants.
✔ HOA Restrictions:  If your property is in a community with a homeowners association (HOA), ensure rentals are allowed and review any rules.

Tip:  Research local rental demand and pricing trends to determine your property’s potential profitability.

Understand Local Rental Laws

Pennsylvania has landlord-tenant laws that govern security deposits, lease agreements, and eviction procedures. Key regulations to be aware of:

  • Security deposits are capped at two months’ rent for the first year. Any amount over one month’s rent (including pet deposit) after one year occupancy is to be returned to the tenant.
  • Landlords must return security deposits within 30 days of a tenant moving out.
  • Proper eviction procedures must be followed, including providing written notice when required.

 

Tip:  Consult a local real estate attorney or property management company to stay compliant with the law.

Set Competitive Rental Rates

Charging the right rent is crucial for attracting and keeping tenants. Factors to consider:

  • Comparable Market Rates:  Research similar rentals in your area.
  • Seasonal Demand:  Short-term rental rates may fluctuate based on peak tourist seasons.
  • Property Features:  Homes with amenities like hot tubs, fireplaces, or lake access can command higher rent.

 

Tip:  If your property is vacant for long periods, consider adjusting your pricing strategy or offering move-in incentives.

Screen Tenants Carefully

A thorough tenant screening process helps prevent future issues. When evaluating applicants:

✔ Check credit reports for payment history.

✔ Verify employment and income to ensure affordability.

✔ Contact previous landlords for rental history.

✔ Run a background check for criminal or eviction history.

Consider using a platform like RentSpree* or something comparable. You might also consider using The Guarantors* or something comparable that offers rent coverage, security deposit and renters insurance.

Tip:  Follow Fair Housing Laws to ensure an equal and legal screening process.

*Mention of products/services is not an endorsement.

Maintain the Property & Address Repairs Quickly

Keeping your rental in top shape ensures tenant satisfaction and property value retention.

  • Schedule regular maintenance for HVAC, plumbing, and roofing.
  • Respond quickly to repair requests to build a positive landlord-tenant relationship.
  • Have a network of reliable contractors for emergency repairs.

 

Tip:  Conduct seasonal inspections to catch issues early and prevent costly repairs.

Consider Property Management Services

Managing a rental can be time-consuming, especially if you own multiple properties or live out of town. A property management company can handle:


✔ Tenant screening and leasing.
✔ Rent collection and financial management.
✔ Maintenance and emergency repairs.
✔ Legal compliance and eviction processes.

 

Tip:  Factor management fees into your budget and weigh the benefits of hands-off rental ownership.

Final Thoughts

Being a successful landlord in the Poconos requires smart property selection, legal awareness, and attentive tenant management. Whether you’re renting to vacationers or long-term tenants, a well-maintained and properly managed property can generate steady income and long-term wealth.

Looking to invest in Pocono real estate or need help managing your rental? Contact me today for expert guidance!

Picture of Meagan Lahey

Meagan Lahey

I'm Meagan Lahey, a dedicated REALTOR® at eXp Realty LLC, residing and working in the beautiful Pocono Mountains alongside my family and my dog, Cleo. I have always had a thirst for knowledge for this area and continuously strive to uncover its hidden gems and history. I'll be sharing my personal journey with those that live here and those considering a move to this remarkable place. Stay informed about all the exciting happenings in the Poconos by following me. Let's embark on this adventure together!