What's Happening
If you’re searching for a spacious rental in the Pocono Mountains and need at least three bedrooms and two bathrooms, this April 2025 market update is for you. Whether you’re relocating from NYC/NJ, moving up from a smaller space, or just craving the mountain lifestyle, here’s what’s happening in Monroe County’s rental market right now.
Let’s break it down.
Average Rent Is Holding Steady
For 3 bed/2 bath homes, the average monthly rent came in at $2,068—a number that’s held fairly consistent over the last few months. If your budget is in the $2,000+ range, you’re sitting in the sweet spot of where this market is performing.
Most homes rented between $1,500 and $2,500, but the $2,000–$2,200 price point saw a lot of activity. At that price, tenants are expecting move-in-ready homes in safe, accessible neighborhoods.
If you upgrade your budget a bit then you can upgrade your wants to a “short-term rental” style home with bonus features like a finished basement, garage, or updated kitchen and bathrooms.
Average Time on Market: 76 Days
On average, it took 76 days for these rentals to go under contract in April, which is slightly longer than usual for this time of year. But don’t let that fool you—the best homes are still going fast.
The full range was anywhere from 5 days to 244 days, so timing really depends on the home’s condition, location, and price point. Homes that check all the boxes—clean, updated, and well-priced—are getting scooped up quickly.
Only 14 Homes (3/2) Rented in April
There were just 14 three-bedroom/two bathroom homes rented in Monroe County last month. That’s a small number for a growing area, and it reflects limited inventory—especially for families, remote workers, and relocators looking for a longer-term solution in the $2,000+ range.
If you’ve been watching the market, you probably already know: there’s more demand than supply, and competition can be stiff. Being prepared with your application, income docs, and credit info up front can make or break your chance at landing a great home.
What Does This Mean for You?
If you’re actively searching, this is not the time to hesitate once you find the right fit. I recommend touring homes as soon as they hit the market, especially those between $1,900–$2,300. Many landlords are prioritizing stable income, strong credit, and long-term leases, so it pays to get your ducks in a row early.
I’m happy to help guide you through the process—whether you’re new to the Poconos or just moving to a different community nearby. I’ve got a system to make things smooth, fast, and stress-free, and I can also help you prepare for the transition if you’re moving here from another state.
Final Thoughts
Living in the Poconos means you get the best of both worlds—peaceful mountain living with access to all the essentials. From breathtaking parks and outdoor adventures to a strong sense of community and year-round events, there’s always something to enjoy. Whether you’re working from home or raising a family, the Poconos offers a lifestyle that’s both grounded and full of possibility. Once you’re here, it’s hard to imagine living anywhere else!
Want To See What’s Currently Available?
Let’s talk! Call/text me at 570-730-1205 or email [email protected]. I’ll send you my current rental list and a free guide on what to expect when renting in the Poconos.
